Saturday, July 28, 2012
Our Covered Wagon
From Indiana to Kansas
Yesterday Camilla commented that we made a detour to New Castle Indiana on our way to Indianapolis. In 1863 Elial was based in New Castle, teaching, writing for and selling The Indiana School Journal.
He had not had a stable career. During the 1850s he moved yearly. He rarely stayed in one school longer than 2 years. Why was this? He may have been a difficult person, he may have had ideas about education that were not shared by principals or trustees. He may have alienated ministers, other teachers, and parents. The evidence from the early 1860s when he is traveling throughout Indiana suggests that he was pushing pedagogical reform that was not uniformly warmly received. He was, for example, challenging the hegemony of the McGuffey’s reader widely used as the standard classroom text in this period.
He advocated shortening the school day (Camilla would approve of this), incorporating physical education and arts into the curriculum. Elial may not have lasted in New Castle with what were, in his day, fairly radical ideas about the importance of physical education, but they did ultimately learn his lesson. Today, New Castle may have a downtown that looks bombed out, with no viable economic base, but they do celebrate that they have the largest high school gymnasium in the country [see Wikipedia entry for New Castle, Indiana]. Their children may not be able to get jobs but they will be able to exercise.
Elial had met Laura Rice when they were both teaching at the Genesee and Wyoming Seminary, in Alexander NY, a short five hour walk from Warsaw. There Laura, having graduated from Mount Holyoke, was teaching modern languages and history. Elial arrived in 1859.
By the next year, 1860, he had moved on to head the Savannah Male and Female Academy, in Savannah Ohio, near his hometown. Laura’s childhood friend and fellow MHC graduate Mary Foster joined Elial at Savannah after teaching at the Western Female Seminary in Oxford Ohio. He married Laura in June of 1861 after pursuing her quite persistently for two years. After they married, she joined him at Savannah, where she was listed as the Associate Principal at Savannah.
This was the beginning of a partnership that was not simply about marriage but also work. Laura would give birth to their daughter Jay Nettie (known in the family as Aunt Dede) in 1862 in Indiana but she also spoke of teaching while Elial traveled throughout the state recruiting for the Teacher’s Institutes they sponsored.
Laura and Elial spent the Civil War working to improve education in Indiana. Elial was exempted from the draft, the draft records state that he had a “general disability” which was not specified. My grandmother and Elial’s granddaughter used to tell me that he had a “lung problems.” They moved to Colorado, she would tell me, for the air. This was not uncommon as many thought that the drier air of the Southwest would cure what today we’d call chronic respiratory, or lung, distress (and ultimately failure).
In 1866, Elial was elected to be one of the founding faculty of the University of Kansas in Lawrence. How did this happen? He had been working as superintendent of schools in Evansville Kansas, so he clearly had administrative experience, but he also had good political connections in the form of Kansas Senator Edmond Ross. Elial was Ross’ uncle and a close one at that. Elial had many years previously stepped in to help his sister raise Edmond and his brother when Sylvester Ross, a newspaper editor in northeastern Ohio, had died of cholera. No doubt Edmond felt some obligation and commitment to his uncle Elial when he recommended him for the job as University trustee and faculty member.
Elial very quickly alienated his colleagues. Writing about Elial’s time at the University of Kansas, Douglas Harvey, a historian at the University has said:
KU named him “Chair of Belles Lettres and Mental and Moral Philosophy” as well as faculty president. This latter title notwithstanding, Rice was essentially little more than a first among equals. By most measures, his status was no greater than that of Snow and Robinson, but he considered these younger men his inferiors and made little attempt to conceal this attitude.
Coupled with his quick temper and poor health, Rice managed to alienate both of his colleagues as well as many students. The resulting personality conflicts caused the Regents to demote Rice to “acting president,” which only added to his irritation. When Rice sought the first recorded instance of “spousal accommodation” at KU and tried to have his wife installed as “female professor,” the ensuing heated arguments with the Regents led him to look elsewhere for employment.
I’m most intrigued by his statement about “spousal accommodation” because this suggests that Laura’s career and desire to work was respected by Elial. He might have been worried about money but he was earning $1600 – far more than he had probably earned before. He found a new job – at Baker University – a short distance down the road from Lawrence, in Baldwin City. And here, he was appointed President and Laura was made a professor of French and Latin.
To conclude this day of fact (as opposed to Camilla who posts on the “fun”): Again, I’m struck about the locations of the moves made by Elial and Laura. With the move to Lawrence and Baldwin City they were moving to a part of Kansas steeped in anti-slavery activism. Three miles east of Baldwin City, John Brown and his followers had, in 1856, successfully fought attempts by pro-slavery advocates to make Kansas a slave state. They had started their relationship and careers in western New York and northeastern Ohio, areas that had a deep commitment to a reform agenda. In the interim they had spent 6 years in Indiana, in a state much more resistant to their ideas – unwilling, for example, to enact laws allowing towns to levy education taxes (some things don’t change – Indiana residents are still unwilling to tax themselves). They may have felt that Kansas would be more open to their ideas.
Friday, July 27, 2012
Day 3 – Indianapolis, IN
Thursday, July 26, 2012
Day 2 – Columbus/Dublin, OH
Fancy fancy!
We found Thomas Rice…
…Lucindia Rice (Thomas’ wife)…
…Shalor Rice (Thomas and Lucy’s son)…
…Dolly Rice (Thomas and Lucy’s daughter)…
…and this group tombstone to Perez Rice, Lucy Rice, “Father and Mother,” and someone who's name we couldn't read but was Perez's son.
Because we’re a dorky family, we also read a number of other stones here – actually, this cemetery was small enough that we were able to read all of them. In the process, we discovered that ol’ Perez Rice a second tombstone all to himself!
Women's Rights in Upstate New York
I have may have moved through the Women’s Rights National Historic Park in Seneca Falls more quickly than Camilla but that doesn’t mean that I didn’t find it interesting. Two things especially caught my eye.
The first was the picture of the railroad map of New York from 1856 – posted here. I know that it’s hard to read but all those little squiggly lines you see were railroad lines. This picture brought home to me the way that the railroad was the Internet of the 19th century (followed closely by the telegraph). The first train to Wyoming county (where Warsaw NY is located) was in 1843 to nearby Attica (yes, the home of the prison). First train into Warsaw directly was in 1852. In 1849 the local train fare was .90 first class, .57 second class, and .48 emigrant. Certainly travel wasn’t fast since they moved at an average of 26 miles per hour.
Reformers crisscrossed New York by train, bringing their messages to communities large and small. As Camilla said in her post yesterday, this area was a hot bed of radicalism.In preparation for this trip I read back issues from the early 1850s of the Wyoming County Mirror, published in Warsaw NY. How were people in Warsaw responding to the reform movements and activism in upstate New York? If the newspaper is any indication, they were surprisingly informed and supportive of the abolition movement and women’s rights. They also promoted temperance and they were committed to improving the common, or public, school system, and especially eager to professionalize teaching. One of the first anti-slavery societies in the United States was formed in Warsaw in 1833. The Liberty Party, the first political party to call for the end of slavery, was was born there in 1839 – it’s followers later became part of the Free Soil Party out of which the Republican Party evolved in 1856. In Wyoming County 15 individuals were identified as "station-masters" and "conductors" for the Underground Railroad, several of these were prominent citizens of Warsaw.
Laura Rice grew up in this milieu. In 1848 (or the 1968 of the 19th century – figuratively speaking – the year John Noyes arrived to start his Perfectionist community in Oneida and the women’s rights “Declaration of Sentiments” was issued) Laura was 16 years old and probably eager to know about the social movements surrounding her. We know there were reformist inclinations among other family members. Her father Cyrus was an original supporter and subscriber to the Warsaw public (or free) library. He was a man who clearly supported extending education. Laura’s older sister Roxie Rice was a member of a church which “from its beginning took radical ground upon the question of slavery: in 1851 a declaration was made upon the subject, condemning in the most emphatic language, not only slavery itself, but every form of alliance with it.”
In 1852 Laura is listed in a newspaper account as attending a Teacher’s Institute in Warsaw. The goal of these Institutes was to professionalize teaching. They pushed for uniform codes of education and for improved teaching methods. Here teachers could hear, as Laura did, education reformers Horace Greeley and Emma Willard discuss their efforts to promote education.
So important was education to the citizens of Wyoming County that every issue has an article on education featured front and center of the first page. Laura would have seen a call for higher educational standards every time she opened the paper. The surrounding articles highlighted other social issues. Articles for temperance – a favorite issue for reformers – show up regularly. More importantly, the newspaper also advocated the complete integration of women into the educational system. Lobbying for universal and practical education, the editors wrote, ”we insist the Woman, like Man, shall be left free to acquire such an education and pursue such occupations as her own sense of fitness and propriety shall dictate.” (June 29, 1852, p.1)
Articles/notices about woman’s rights meetings by Stanton, Lucy Stone and Paulina Davis were featured regularly. Editors applaud the fact that a Mrs Dolley has taken up practicing medicine in Rochester...”We rejoice, too, because it shows that another avenue is opened for the development and profitable employment of female talent. This a practical assertion of Woman’s Rights. Let her demonstrate that she is capable of rendering the community good service in the practice of this profession, and we have no doubt it will soon pave the way to the opening of avenues to other employments, where she will find full scope for her mental and physical powers, and in which she may obtain, by her own industry and skill, a pecuniary independence.” [August 17, 1852]
The second feature of the Women’s Right exhibit that caught my eye was a poster of a picture of Amelia Bloomer in her notorious bloomers outfit. Bloomer was widely castigated for her outfit – and while many dress reformers of the day tried wearing bloomers, most quickly succumbed to public ridicule and gave it up. The Wyoming Mirror however had a much more positive view of the outfit, running an article in April 1853 on “bloomerism” lauding her clothing, the author noting “I have rarely seen a woman so elegantly, so becomingly, so conveniently dressed as Mrs. Bloomer”. They found her outfit “pleasing to the beholder, more comfortable to the wearer.”
Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Day 1 -- Photo Gallery
I try to revive a fallen pioneer.
My friend Tako-Tako (the silvery tentacled lump there) isn't so sure how he feels about this adventure, probably mostly because he's stuck riding pig-back.
The Community House in Oneida. This picture doesn't even begin to cover how huge it is.
Wesleyan Church in Seneca Falls, where all those conniving feminist types continue to make trouble to this very day.
One picture out of many, many taken of the waterfalls in the Letchworth Park.
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Day 1 -- Geneseo, NY
To kick off our journey, we stopped for a photo shoot at a covered wagon train outside of a barbecue joint in Schenectady. Unfortunately we are having some technical difficulties at the moment and can't get the photos off of my camera, so you guys will have to wait for that. On our way to said barbecue joint we also happened to pass a Rice Road.
Our next stop, thanks to an impromptu detour, was Oneida, once home to Oneida Silver, which was founded by the Oneida Community. The Community, we found out, was a commune of Perfectionists (i.e. pro-utopian -- not a commune of detail-oriented individuals) founded by a man named John Noyes, and held values that were remarkably ahead of their time. Radical notions the Community put forward included complete equality between men and women and that men were responsible for contraception. The Community disbanded after a generation or so, and the sprawling Community House now contains some private residents and a little museum (which has the nicest, loveliest, cleanest museum bathroom I have ever seen, but that is neither here nor there).
Since Elial Rice taught in Oneida after he graduated from Madison College, Susan wonders what he would have thought about what was going in the Community. Would he have been drawn to their Perfectionism? Would he have been scandalized by the equality, both intellectual and sexual, between men and women?
After lunch we made our way to Seneca Falls, the birthplace of the Women's Rights Movement. This was particularly exciting for me, as both a Mount Holyoke student and a former camper at a girls' sleep away camp with a number of cabins named after an assortment of important feminist figures and places, Seneca Falls included. We eventually ended up in the museum next to Wesleyan Chapel, with an exhibit on the Women's Rights Movement and feminism that Susan breezed through because she knows it all already. I ended up buying a suffrage banner, which I will hang proudly in my dorm room this year.
Two or so hours later we arrived in Geneseo, which is east of Warsaw. We went to have dinner in Letchworth State Park, first hiking all around the waterfalls in order to "earn our food." In spite of this being a drier summer than usual, the falls were pretty incredible. I thought it was especially cool how you could see multiple years of repeated erosion at different water levels on the rock of the canyon walls, but then I have a deep love of rocks and am a pretty big nature geek in general. The food at the Glen Iris Inn was absolutely spectacular, if a little more expensive than we're used to. Since the portions are also bigger, however, we're pretty sure it works out.
All in all, the trip is off the a wonderful start! Tomorrow we set out for northeastern Ohio, where Elial was from. With any luck, we'll be able to start putting up pictures too. Stay tuned for Day 2!














